50. The Punk and the Godfather (Why It Matters Revisited)

Hey all right, it's mine! Mine all mine!

 This is the big number fifty in my ongoing narrative, not including the many sidebars and asides.  This seems like a good of a time as any for a sanity check.

I started this project with one intention:  to demonstrate how important music truly is.  It is a wonder drug soothing broken hearts and conjuring lost memories; binding friendships and speaking for us when we can’t speak for ourselves.  It reaches across both time and space.  For a lot of us it is our first unique identities — unique to us, anyway — and for some, usually bald and big-bellied and high-fiving from the front row of a Rush concert, those first identities remain with us forever.

If you have been reading along with me (and if you haven’t, welcome) then you know that I was a proud member of the Guys In Black Tee Shirts Who Jam, a moniker of my own creation as “redneck” and “metalhead” seemed inaccurate.  Before that I was a Barry Manilow fan, which in retrospect must have been frightening for my parents — especially my father, who already was convinced that I was a sissy.  Before that I was just a pup with some hand-me-down records, hardly an identity.

I am just old enough that my earliest musical memories foot to the British Invasion and its aftermath.  The Beatles still loomed large in the early Seventies as a cultural rather than a marketing force.  They were still of the world, not yet gods.  Their songs were performed by school choirs and  were still in heavy rotation all over the dial.  We still clung to the possibility that they would reunite.  They were not yet The Beatles, the elder statesmen, the martyrs, the legends.

Well, they were legends even then.  They were the great wind that blew British pop culture to my houses in Denver, Chicago, Texas, South Carolina,  and in their wake came the other Brit bands.  I repeatedly checked out the only rock and roll book in my third grade library just to look at the photos of The Beatles, The Rolling Stones, The Animals, Herman’s Hermits, The Kinks, T. Rex, Elton, and The Who:  Pete leaping in his Doc Martens and jumpsuit; Roger in his nut huggers and his little sister’s shirt, twirling the microphone.

I guess my point is that music was decidedly British, and I caught I slight case of Anglophilia as a result.  It  was not the “adore the Royal Family” flavor of Anglophilia, nor was it the “Boxing Day and tea time” variant.  I will confess to a love of British television, mind you, but I’m not going to eat Heinz Baked Beans for breakfast.  No, what I really envied were those amazing UK musical identities:  Teddy Boy, Mod, Rocker, Glam, Punk, Rude Boy.

Now here’s the thing:  I love my Beatles and my Bowie but in my opinion the single most important songwriter of the last sixty years is The Who’s Pete Townshend.  What an amazing body of work that man has created, from the criminally self-indulgent to the most emotionally poignant and accessible pop songs to ever hit the radio. “Nobody knows what it’s like / To be the bad man / To be the sad man / Behind blue eyes.”   Sing it, brother.  I’ll raise my hand and give you an amen.

I identified with Pete:  tall, big-nosed, bright-eyed, awkward; introspective, angry, lonely, searching.  Sensitive. Hell, I’ve come this far, I may as well be honest —  I still identify with Pete.  I’m getting older and balder.  My nose is growing along with my gut and my insecurities.  I am mad at the world but I love it dearly.  I have to make art whether you like it or not so fuck you, but won’t you please love me?

My friend Matt, he of the satellite dish and VCR, my connection for music videos, shared my love for The Who.  We wailed “Baba O’Riley” in the halls and debated the lyrics.  We tried to map the ground between The Who and The Clash, usually using the Sex Pistols’ “Substitute” as a lazy crutch.

Matt recorded Ken Russell’s film version of Tommy for me, which I hated with exception to the spank bank-worthy sight of Ann Margret  orgasmically rolling around in the aforementioned baked beans.  He  recorded The Kids Are All Right, too, still my favorite Who documentary.  The sight of a bloated Keith Moon looking twenty years older than he should is  heartbreaking, but that film also includes the most iconic power slide in rock movie history.

But where Matt really got me was with a copy of 1979’s Quadrophenia, featuring a non-lute playing Sting as Ace Face.  If you’ve read this far I doubt that you need me to tell you that Quadrophenia was The Who’s next rock opera after Tommy.  Between these two was a massive project named Lifehouse that collapsed under its own weight and became Who’s Next, arguably the band’s greatest album.

Quadrophenia.  Jimmy Cooper, the Mod with his GS scooter and his Army jacket, chasing the Rockers through Brighton.  Is was just too much for me, and sometimes it still is.  Just last week it crossed my mind to buy an old Lambretta and dress it in full kit: the mirrors, the antennae, the whole bit.  During my years in Los Angeles I’d go to the Hard Rock Cafe not to eat the cruddy food but to be close to Jimmy’s scooter for a moment.

I wanted to be a Mod, but I couldn’t.  It was a musical identity that belonged to both the past and to a different culture.  I was a South Carolina kid in the Eighties, not a Brit in the Sixties.  It would have been like a white kid trying to be black, or a sane person liking Nickelback.  So I simply revered the Mods, even though my beloved Beatles were Teddy Boys and then Rockers.  Deep down I was a Mod — my own little secret while I tooled around on my silver Honda while wearing my field jacket.  Only love can make it rain, but only Pete can pick up a stray from twenty years and several thousand miles away.

That’s why music matters, goddamnit — it connects us.  Thanks to the intergooglewebtubes I am sure of it, as a GS scooter just parked at my door and its driver as much as told me so.  Yet another best friend that I will never meet left this comment on a recent post:

A great read! I go back to the 60′s; I am an original Mod. Mods being the youth culture of the time in my home town – London.

For no other generation did music have such a high-emotional-value. Music as we know it today was in its infancy; and the pleasure of discovering ‘new’ sounds was a penetration of bright colour into the grey world that surrounded us.

Dare I say that bands such as the Who and the Stones, would not of made it without their strong Mod following. Tamla and soul would of remained lost on African American radio stations, hidden from a music hungry world!

I love music for music’s sake, my musical soul takes me in all directions of genre. There is no better way to ride those musical waves!

– Alex Johnson,

 Preach it, godfather.  I’m waving my hand and shouting amen.


Related  “Why It Matters” pieces:

I find The Beatles:

My brief Manilow madness:

First Who:

But my first real Who moment:

What Mr. Johnson was commenting on:

10 replies »

  1. I came to The Who in adulthood. When I was a kid, I didn’t find their music as relatable, as say, The Beatles or The Rolling Stones. Looking back, I couldn’t really say why.
    I did appreciate the Mod sartorial sensibilities, as they reappeared in the late 70s and early 80s. Nothing like a man in tight trousers and a skinny tie….


    • I think The Who are harder for younger kids to get into because Pete always wrote like an old man, even when he was writing about the kids. Well, maybe not “My Generation” and “I’m the Face,” but beyond that.


  2. Lets lead with the ‘humour’ shall we. I confess a large laugh at the line “like a sane person liking Nickleback”. Nickleback confirms all my fears and suspicions that I try to keep in check about popular music. But this thread of conversation is for another time.

    Additionally your oratorical prose did not put my fears to rest at the large plausibility of you sitting at high tea room covered in chintz lightly caressing your limited edition princess Di collector teacup, ever so slightly sipping your Earl Grey. Confess James! Confess! 😛

    I have to admit I love the music of the UK in all it’s forms. I am convinced that you can’t compete in certain ways with a people who have existed for thousands of years. The Who, The Beatles, at the time, were the “new now” but all the time roads musically lead to them that magical fission.

    My next few observations might put your panties in a twist. The style I tend to see *thematically* parallel to Brits in the vein of The Who or The Beatles exist in country music and the blues (no, not Billy Ray Sirus country) but in musicians such as Johnny Cash, Skip James or in a quick fast forward to now Bonnie ‘Prince’ Billy.

    Interms of looking at something new, in your case the ‘Mods’ and feeling like you couldn’t emulate for fear of…

    I believe the effect music has on us mentally provides a bridge to guide us to the better understanding of cultures, people or ideas that once were not close to our own. It’s a process that lets explore other possibilities or personas. I don’t believe there is anything inherently wrong with the white kid embracing black culture and “feeling it” or you feeling yourself being tugged to be a ‘Mod’. How can you not be impacted by a style of music or an idea and then shards & dust of not permeate you.

    And I end with a confession. I adore the Beatles and whole british infection but the 2 seminal Brit music acts that have affected me so much that the altered my DNA have to be Robert Wyatt (+soft machine) and Brian Eno.


    • My panties are notably untwisted, thank you. You’re absolutely right that country music was a big influence on the Brit Invasion; after all, The Beatles covered Buck Owens’s “Act Naturally,” for example. And Johnny Cash was an original Sun Records rocker, remember — right there with Elvis and Carl Perkins. Anyhoo, I should probably save this juice for an actual write up, but the point is that it’s all intermingled.

      Re: “Feeling it” versus “trying to be it.” The Dalai Lama has said, and I’m paraphrasing here, that if you’re from a Western country and want to be a good Buddhist then be a good Christian, because that’s your cultural frame of reference and it will get you to the same place. That’s kind of what I’m gunning for here. The Red Hot Chili Peppers make great funk but they come from what they know as opposed to adopting some posture that they don’t. I like that — absorb the influences and make it your own, you know? And maybe even more appropriately, I just thought it was cool that something I wrote would resonate with one of the original Mods almost fifty years later — sort of points out that “Mod” was in the spirit of the thing, not in the accessories. Or something like that.

      Finally: You can’t go wrong with Robert Wyatt and Eno, proving once and for all that you have exquisite taste.


  3. As a Brit I am sitting here with a big smile on my face…

    Mind you, I still quite like Barry Manilow…

    After The Beatles you do wonder why anyone tries to make music…


  4. As I wasn’t a kid in 80-s and other earlier memorable times for British music, I like this sort of reading with memories and recollections of the past. It’s like getting pieces of the legendary past from people who actually witnessed it. Thanks a lot for this read 🙂


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.